As smartphones become ubiquitous, the debate over the “right” age for a child to get their first device is intensifying. New research provides strong evidence for delaying this milestone, suggesting that children who own a smartphone before the age of 12 face significantly higher risks of negative health outcomes, including mental health struggles, poor sleep, and obesity.
The study, which analyzed data from over 10,500 children participating in the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development Study in the US, reinforces a growing scientific consensus: the age at which a child receives a smartphone matters deeply for their long-term well-being.
The Associated Health Risks
The findings, published in the journal Pediatrics, revealed a clear association between early smartphone access and several poor health indicators among tweens:
- Mental Health: Children who acquired a smartphone by age 12 were found to be at a higher risk of depression and other harmful mental health symptoms. Furthermore, a follow-up with children who received a device a year later also showed a noticeable deterioration in mental health symptoms compared to their peers who did not receive one.
- Poor Sleep: Earlier smartphone ownership was directly correlated with insufficient sleep. Devices in the bedroom are a primary culprit; one associated study found that 63% of 11- to 12-year-olds had an electronic device in their sleeping area, with nearly 17% being awakened by phone notifications in a given week.
- Obesity: The research also found a correlation between early smartphone access and higher rates of obesity. This risk is likely tied to the device displacing essential healthy activities, such as in-person socializing, physical exercise, and adequate sleep.
Experts caution that while the study demonstrates a strong association, it does not prove direct cause-and-effect. However, they note that the loss of crucial time spent on activities essential for well-being—like exercise and sleep—is likely the mechanism driving these negative health changes. Adolescence is a highly sensitive time for development, and even modest disturbances to sleep or social life can have profound and lasting effects.
Navigating the Digital Divide: Advice for Parents
Researchers are clear that the intent of the study is not to shame parents but to provide actionable data. The primary takeaway is the significant difference that age makes. “A kid at age 12 is very, very different than a kid at age 16,” noted the study’s lead author.
For parents struggling to decide when to yield to their pleading children—the median age for first smartphone ownership in the study was 11—experts offer practical advice:
- Delay When Possible: Caregivers are encouraged to trust their instincts and hold off on providing a smartphone until they feel the family is truly ready. It is important to view the decision as a significant health choice, not just a matter of convenience.
- Prioritize Sleep: This is the simplest and most agreed-upon intervention. Families should enforce a strict rule to keep all smartphones out of the bedroom overnight, preventing both blue light interference and disruptive notifications.
- Establish Strong Limits: If a device is necessary, parents must commit to the “very hard work of putting protections and limits in place,” especially considering that the device grants access to “everything on the internet.”
The ultimate goal, researchers state, is for parents, policymakers, and society to work together to mitigate the risks associated with early smartphone ownership for the sake of children’s long-term health.
Leave a Reply